Doxagora
America, Considered.
HOME
babbler@gmail.com

BLOGS

Rittenhouse The CJR of blogs. Say hi to Mildred while you're there.
Skippy lower-case lefty with laughs.
World Wide Rant Now with 38% less ranting! Spin-free commentary with cross-ideological biases.
Cold Spring Shops Top-notch conservative writing on economics and academia.
Brad DeLong Top-notch liberal writing on economics and academia.
Eschaton No introduction necessary.
How Appealing Howard Bashman's blog on appellate decisions and litigation, now hosted by Legal Affairs magazine.
CJR Campaign Desk Ooooh: Earnesty.
Volokh Again, no intro needed.
Legal Theory 100% of your RDA of esoteric legal theory.
Pandagon I don't need to introduce Jesse either.
Juan Cole U-Mich MES prof does Iraq.
Flogging the Simian The absolute best news source for all things Jack Idema. Soj does things from Romanian net cafes that reporters can't, or won't, do from the NYT.
Hemlock More of a diarist than a blogger, Hemlock reads like two parts Hunter S. Thompson to one part Evelyn Waugh, with a jigger of Kipling thrown in for spice.
Webb Site David Webb on Hong Kong corporate governance and political governance, which often seems to be the same thing.
Mystery Pollster No mystery here: pollster Mark Blumenthal's site is top-drawer specialist commentary on the art and science of public opinion.
4x4 Land Use One-stop shopping for roadless rule and national park info. Monitors land use regulations and legislation from a mechanized-use perspective.
Ragged Thots GOP insiders and NY Post editor Robert A. George. Politics, comics, commentary.
Coalition of the Swilling Because given New Jersey gun laws, these are the only shots they'll get.
The Washington Note Insiderish foreign policy blog.
Slacktivist Once bitten, twice born progressive.


ANALYSES
ABC's "The Note"
The Green Papers
CampaignLine
Politics1

POLLING & RESEARCH
Polling Report
FEC Contribution Data
IRS 8871/8872 Database

PRIMARY SOURCES
Presidential Documents
Federal Register
Agency Regulations
Federal Contracts
SCOTUS Opinions
THOMAS
GAO Reports
FDLP Full Text Collections
State of the States



Tuesday, March 09, 2004
 
Andrew Sullivan finds a putative Kerry malapropism in a letter from a reader:

My brother, Sean, debated Kerry back in 1970-71. Sean was a leader in Vietnam Veterans for a Just Peace. He and a colleague lunching with Kerry one time, before or after a debate, believe it or not.
Discussing some moral point or other, Kerry came out with: 'You just have to understand the higher modalities of the situation.'
This has been a catchphrase in our family ever since.

(The always-readable Tim Blair also picks up on it.)


Perhaps I'm misunderstanding the humor in the phrase, but I assumed that Kerry meant "deontic modalities" (i.e., rules of ethical behavior mandating that acts be obligatory, forbidden, or permissible). Although an idiosyncratic turn of phrase, it would certainly make sense if, for example, Kerry were defending a course of action against a consequentialist argument: "Regardless of the outcome of this act, I must do it because I am obligated to do it (or forbidden from doing it)." In other words, there's nothing particularly notable in Kerry's use of words, except that he was probably exposed to Kantian philosophy and probably never to modal logic at some point in his undergraduate career. (Sullivan, as an Oakeshottian, should well remember the many faces of modal logic, though I don't know Oakeshott's work well enough to know if he ever scrutinized deontology in so many words.)


Even if Kerry wasn't caught in a malapropism, there's still something amusing to me about his using a deontological argument in ethics, given the flip-flopping that seems to have been the hallmark of his political career. (Here's a modality for you: "It is forbidden to throw away another man's medals and claim them for your own.") But we'll leave that for another time.

posted by Watchful at 9:01 PM



ARCHIVES
Doxagora is copyright (C) 2003 the respective authors. All rights reserved.